0:00
/
0:00
Transcript

The Content Creator Trap That Keeps Coaches Broke

A livestream replay about how to stop trying to be a content creator and start attracting paying clients with your videos

Views don’t pay bills. If your livestreams aren’t converting, you’re probably stuck in the content creator trap—and you don’t even know it.


Thank you La Vonne Grace, Dee Batiste, and many others for tuning into my live video! Join me for my next live video in the app.


I’ve been there. I chased a trending TikTok “boat” moment to qualify for livestreaming privileges. It worked. I gained a thousand followers quickly. The trade-off? Most of those followers came for the trend, not my coaching. They didn’t convert. That moment taught me something I now tell every client: growth for the sake of numbers is wasted effort when your goal is client acquisition.

If you’re a coach, consultant, strategist, or service provider, showing up on camera should do one thing above all else: attract the right clients. Too many people confuse attention with authority. They copy trending creator formats, pile on flashy production, and wonder why views aren’t translating into booked calls and paid programs.

Here’s the distinction in one sentence: Creators optimize for views, virality, and algorithm appeal. Coaches should optimize for trust, demonstrated methodology, and conversion readiness.

Platforms reward attention. Algorithms favor hooks, transitions, and short loops that keep people scrolling. Coaches see those formats succeed and mimic them. The result is often a steady cadence of admirable content that ultimately doesn’t convert because the objective was entertainment, not transformation.

When your job is service and transformation, the form should serve conversion.

Three Authority-Building Formats That Actually Convert

Choosing an intentional format is the single most practical change you can make. Each of these demonstrates different aspects of professional coaching—and all three improve conversion readiness. Pick one as your anchor and rotate the others in.

Chaos to Clarity (C2C)

Diagnose the messy. Name the real problem. Reframe it so a path forward appears.

This format works when your audience is overwhelmed, stuck, or drowning in conflicting advice. You’re demonstrating your ability to cut through noise and deliver a clear diagnosis. When a viewer thinks, “This person gets my problem and could help me,” they’re far more likely to book a call.

Process and Practice (PIP)

Demonstrate your method live—like a chef on a cooking show. Walk through diagnostic questions, decisions, and outcomes. Show one piece of your process in action.

People buy methods, not promises. When you show how you work—a live diagnostic, a client hot seat, a step-by-step walkthrough—prospects can imagine working with you. They see the concrete value before they ever get on a call.

Theory to Truth (T2T)

Connect concept to real-world results. Take a testimonial or coaching win and reverse-engineer it into a case study. Teach the theory, then walk through the actual implementation and outcome.

Case studies reduce risk for prospects and accelerate decision-making. This format builds credibility and social proof simultaneously.

The 3C Live Stream Compass: Your Five-Minute Planning System

Before every stream, run through three questions:

Clarify: What’s the one transformation you’ll deliver? Pick a single, measurable outcome the audience can take away.

Coach: What method will you demonstrate? Which format does this session use? What diagnostic questions, framework, or case snippet will you show?

Convert: What’s the explicit next step? People don’t automatically know what to do after a valuable session. Tell them.

Think of it as: What’s the win, what’s the way, and what’s the next step. When every stream answers those three questions, the path from content to revenue becomes frictionless.

Matching Content to Purpose

Not all content needs to sell directly. But clarity about purpose solves downstream problems. I map every piece of content to one of four objectives:

  • Awareness — Short, curiosity-driven content that introduces your perspective

  • Bonding — Stories and small wins that build familiarity and likability

  • Conversion — Demonstrations, case studies, and CTAs that invite action

  • Delight — Client updates, behind-the-scenes, and testimonials that retain customers

Mix formats, but always know which job each piece of content is doing.

Mindset Shifts That Make This Work

Abundance over scarcity. Teaching parts of your process doesn’t exhaust your offers. People rarely implement everything from one session—teaching builds trust and curiosity for deeper work.

Right-size your audience. Not everyone will be a fit. Your job is to attract the right people, not the most people.

Be yourself. Mimicking influencer style only creates friction between your presence and your offer. Authenticity is the most efficient path to authority.

Collect testimonials relentlessly. Stop asking for vague feedback. Ask for short, specific endorsements. Record them. These become raw material for T to T content you can repurpose endlessly.

Tactical Tips for the Stream Itself

Open by naming a problem and promising a clear solution—that’s coach energy, not creator energy. Model the method you teach while teaching it; the performance becomes proof. Use visuals sparingly to support the method, not decorate it. Keep your CTA explicit and repeat it. Close the loop: restate the transformation, summarize the method, tell people the exact next step.

Repurposing Without Losing Conversion Intent

Repurposing is essential—but not all repurposed content should become entertainment. When you chop up a PIP session into short clips, retain the path to action. A clip that educates should end with a single sentence pointing to a next step: the full replay, a worksheet, a discovery call.

Your Three-Step Action Plan

  1. Pick your anchor format. Chaos to Clarity, Process and Practice, or Theory to Truth—choose one and plan your next stream around it.

  2. Run the 3C Compass. Clarify, Coach, Convert. Five minutes of planning that changes everything.

  3. Collect one testimonial this week. After your next client session, ask for a 20-30 second shout-out. Turn it into a T to T case study clip.

The Bottom Line

Livestreaming done strategically is one of the most efficient ways for coaches and consultants to build authority and convert real clients. But only if you stop playing the creator game.

Choose formats that reveal your method. Anchor your planning in Clarify, Coach, Convert. Make conversion the outcome—not an afterthought.

Likes don’t pay the light bill. Clients do.


What format will you try first—C to C, PIP, or T to T? Drop a comment with your choice and one sentence about your offer. I’ll check back and ask how it went.


Get more from Tanya Smith in the Substack app
Available for iOS and Android

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?